The striker guided Djibril Sidibe's cross in to the far corner to wrap up the points for the home side at Goodison Park on Boxing Day. Burnley boss Sean Dyche made two changes to his side with Robbie Brady and Jay Rodriguez replaced suspended Jeff Hendrick and Ashley Barnes. Here are the scores...
1. Nick Pope 6
Made an unbelievable save to deny Holgate from point blank range in the first half and then stuck out a leg to prevent Sidibe from putting the home side in front later on. Couldn't have done anything to keep out Calvert-Lewin's winner.
2. Phil Bardsley 6
His physicality and drive negated the threats of Digne and Bernard, who was eventually replaced by Moise Kean. Won several crunching 50/50 tackles.
3. Charlie Taylor 6
Settled far better in the second half having been stretched once or twice in the first. Calvert-Lewin, Sidibe and Coleman kept the full back occupied throughout, but he stuck to his task well.
4. James Tarkowski 7
Swept everything up whenever Ben Mee wasn't in the vicinity, making a number of key interventions. Calvert-Lewin, however, got across the centre back to convert Everton's late winner.