The home side came from a goal behind to force the shootout after David McGoldrick opened the scoring in the third minute.
Burnley lost Johann Berg Gudmundsson on the quarter-of-an-hour mark as the Icelandic international was left clutching his knee following a challenge from Jack Robinson.
Matej Vydra equalised in the 67th minute when lifting the ball over Wes Foderingham from Jay Rodriguez's cushioned header before the tie went to a shootout.
Chris Wood, Vydra, Josh Brownhill and Erik Pieters all converted before Robbie Brady kept his cool to wrap up the victory.

9. Robbie Brady 6
Worked hard, recovered well when conceding possession, but set-pieces weren't quite on the money. Should have scored when hitting the post in the second half after collecting a Pieters pass, but went on to net the winning penalty in the shootout.

10. Matej Vydra 6
Struggled to get in behind the Blades defence in the first half and failed to make the ball stick. However, refused to shy away and eventually got his goal. Showed real composure to lift the ball over Foderingham. Took his penalty in the shootout well.

11. Jay Rodriguez 6
A fraction away from converting Lowton's cross in the first half. Put himself about to limit the time on the ball for Sheffield United's defenders and provided the assist for Vydra's equaliser with an excellent cushioned header.

12. Erik Pieters 7
Always puts a shift in, never letting his team-mates down. Some of his work goes unnoticed, but the Dutchman picks up good positions to limit the opposition's passing streams and keeps things simple in possession. Scored in the shootout.

