Pundit ponders why Sunderland have been so much more successful than Burnley

While Burnley beat Sunderland at the start of the season, it’s fair to say the two newly-promoted sides have enjoyed contrasting fortunes in the Premier League this season.

placeholder image
Read More
Burnley man stars in Alan Shearer's Premier League team of the week after Totten...

The Black Cats, who host Scott Parker’s side at the Stadium of Light on Monday night, have enjoyed an incredible campaign to date.

Despite finishing 24 points behind Burnley and Leeds United in the Championship last season, Regis Le Bris’ side have outperformed the two automatically promoted sides.

Sunderland sit 11th in the table after 23 games with 33 points to their name, giving them a 13-point cushion to the relegation zone.

Burnley, meanwhile, have won just three times all season and haven’t tasted victory in their last 14 league games, leaving them in 19th and 10 points adrift of safety.

Sky Sports pundit Alan Smith believes contrasting approaches from the two respective managers might help explain the difference in fortunes.

The Burnley Express has launched a new WhatsApp channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our Burnley Express WhatsApp channel.

Burnley actually came out on top against Sunderland earlier in the season (Photo by Matt McNulty/Getty Images)placeholder image
Burnley actually came out on top against Sunderland earlier in the season (Photo by Matt McNulty/Getty Images)

"I don’t think anybody saw this coming really, the brilliant season that Sunderland are enjoying,” he told BestBettingSites.co.uk.

"I think you look at the signings, don’t you? They made so many and we all wondered whether there were too many and whether they could be accommodated in a starting 11. The likes of [Nordi] Mukiele and Granit Xhaka have done really well, and perhaps Burnley’s haven’t done quite so well.

“But also Sunderland’s approach, really attacking positively, maybe Scott Parker is a little bit more cautious and they haven’t been able to build that momentum.

"They’ve been really competitive lately, but they’ve had too many draws, really, to give themselves any hope, I think, of clawing themselves up the table.”

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice