Opinion: Newcastle United defeat perfectly encapsulates Burnley's huge contrast in fortunes in 2025

If ever you needed validation of Burnley’s current day dilemma, the year 2025 perfectly encapsulates their strife.

placeholder image
Read More
Scott Parker addresses Quilindschy Hartman's Burnley future after being dropped ...

It looks for all intents and purposes that the Clarets are the modern-day yo-yo club: too good for the Championship (finishing with 101 and 100 points in back-to-back campaigns), but not up to scratch in the Premier League (24 points under Vincent Kompany, 12 at the halfway stage with Scott Parker).

The year began in the best way possible with yet another victory against that lot down the road – Zian Flemming giving Burnley a 1-0 win at Ewood Park to make it 13 games unbeaten in the second tier.

It ended though with a familiar feeling of dejection, as Parker’s men made it 10 games without a win with a 3-1 defeat at home to Newcastle United, leaving them six points adrift and staring a third straight relegation from this level in the face.

Supporters are understandably fed up of hearing the same explanations and excuses, that’s only natural when the same thing continues to happen week in, week out.

But Parker is right to be delighted with his side’s performance against the Magpies. After a horror start, conceding twice in the first seven minutes, they were the better team by far and should have taken something from the game. Even had they come back to draw, it still would have felt harsh on them, such was their level of performance.

They played with intent, with purpose and with conviction, but it all counts for nothing when they can’t carry out the basics of defending at one end and can’t capitalise on moments of prolonged pressure at the other.

Burnley are now winless in their last 10 games (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)placeholder image
Burnley are now winless in their last 10 games (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)

It’s been said before but I’ll repeat it again, this isn’t even about tactics, personnel or systems, Burnley just don’t have the required quality.

The cold, hard fact is that they have effort and endeavour in abundance, but they’re not good enough to keep the ball out at one end nor score enough goals at the other. That makes for a pretty bleak picture.

The Burnley Express has launched a new WhatsApp channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our Burnley Express WhatsApp channel.

It was quite fitting that this game was televised live on Sky Sports’ tennis channel, because from the start this felt like a chaotic, end-to-end encounter with a constant back and forth.

Marcus Edwards is denied by Newcastle keeper and former Claret Nick Pope (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)placeholder image
Marcus Edwards is denied by Newcastle keeper and former Claret Nick Pope (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)

To continue the tennis metaphor, Burnley suffered a 6-0 thrashing in the first set having conceded twice in the space of the first seven minutes.

In fact, there were just 65 seconds on the clock when Joelinton turned home Anthony Gordon’s deflected cross in from the left. To concede so early – to a side that had only won once on the road beforehand, let’s not forget – is simply excusable.

It’s doubly frustrating in the manner in which Gordon twisted and turned Kyle Walker inside out, because for the remainder of the evening the Burnley man had Gordon’s number.

A long night appeared in store when Yoane Wissa was gifted a simple tap-in from a few yards out after yet more shambolic Burnley defending. Maxime Esteve, clearly not match fit on his return from injury, was at the heart of it and was soon taken off.

Armando Broja can't hide his frustration at the full-time whistle (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)placeholder image
Armando Broja can't hide his frustration at the full-time whistle (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)

While the Clarets deserved to concede for such basic errors in defending, it was a huge surprise to see the goal stand after a clear shove from Bruno Guimaraes on Josh Laurent inside the six-yard box.

Full credit to Burnley’s players though, because they could easily have wilted at this point and gone under. The Turf Moor crowd was ready to turn. But they showed plenty of bottle and character to get up from the canvas and take the game to Newcastle, which is exactly what they did.

They halved the deficit midway through the first-half, Laurent lashing home a first ever Premier League goal with an exquisite first-time volley.

From this point onwards, up until the 80th minute or so, the Clarets were clearly the side in the ascendancy. Indeed, they laid siege to the Newcastle goal at the start of the second-half and it appeared only a matter of time until that equaliser arrived.

But Marcus Edwards, Burnley’s brightest attacking spark on the night, had a one-on-one effort saved by former Claret Nick Pope, Laurent saw a looping header rebound off the woodwork and Loum Tchaouna headed wastefully wide after being left free at the far post.

Burnley can’t say they didn’t have the chances, they had more than enough. But they only have themselves to blame.

Scott Parker reacts at the full-time whistle (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)placeholder image
Scott Parker reacts at the full-time whistle (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)

Nothing left

While both sides are depleted at this moment in time, Burnley’s plight was summed up midway through the second-half when you looked over to the benches to see what changes could be made.

Eddie Howe brought on £110m worth of talent in Jacob Ramsey and Nick Woltemade, while Parker introduced Tresor to play in a central midfield role again while 36-year-old Ashley Barnes went up front for only his second Premier League cameo of the campaign.

The hosts had nothing much left in the tank and all that was left was for the Magpies to make sure of their three points with a third goal, handed to them on a plate by Martin Dubravka’s error – Bruno the grateful recipient.

Going back to tennis for a second, we recently witnessed the bizarre Battle of the Sexes match between Nick Kyrgios and Aryna Sabalenka. But this was a Battle of the Exes – Pope coming out on top against his former employers, while Dubravka was left with egg on his face.

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice