Dermot Gallagher rules on refereeing controversies during Burnley v Newcastle United game

Burnley felt they were on the wrong end of some big officiating calls during their defeat to Newcastle United in midweek.

placeholder image
Read More
Burnley's new predicted final Premier League finish and points tally after Newca...

While the Clarets certainly contributed to their own problems, they were also right to feel aggrieved about some of the decisions from referee Rob Jones that didn’t go their way.

Newcastle’s second goal was allowed to stand in controversial circumstances, while Joelinton avoided a second booking later on in the game.

Those were among the talking points during Sky Sports’ weekly Ref Watch show, where former top flight official Dermot Gallagher provides his analysis and insight on all the major decisions.

Should Newcastle’s second goal have stood?

Yoane Wissa’s goal to double Newcastle’s lead was controversially allowed to stand, despite there being a clear shove on Josh Laurent from Bruno Guimaraes inside the six-yard box, stopping the Burnley man from clearing the ball.

Laurent lays on the ground after being shoved by Bruno Guimaraes for Newcastle's second goal (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)placeholder image
Laurent lays on the ground after being shoved by Bruno Guimaraes for Newcastle's second goal (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)

Gallagher, however, felt it wasn’t a clear and obvious error from the referee to allow the goal to stand.

“If that's going to be given as a foul, it has to be the referee's choice,” he said.

"The first thing he will say to the VAR is 'I don't think there's enough there, I think Guimaraes is standing his ground if you like, the player has gone over too easily'. That will be his call.

“Is it clear and obvious [error]? No.”

Former striker Jay Bothroyd, however, provided a different view.

“This is a tough one,” he said.

"Laurent is trying to shield the ball because he wants his keeper to come and get that. Guimaraes is more 'I want to get the ball' but because he's in they way, he has to nudge him or push him.

“To me, that is a foul because he's pushed him.”

Should Joelinton have been sent off?

Later on in the game, Joelinton was fortunate to escape a second yellow card for Newcastle after stopping Armando Broja during a Burnley break.

But Gallagher once again backed up the referee’s call not to book the Newcastle midfielder.

“Definitely not [a red card],” Gallagher said.

"A foul on the halfway line has different consequences than a foul further up the field because of the ramifications.

“That foul has stopped Broja getting the ball, but he is running into traffic, he does not have green space ahead of him. But further up the field, it is a totally different decision, there are too many variables.”

Bothroyd added: “Not every foul is a yellow card.

"Joelinton is trying to anticipate he is going in a certain direction, he shows a great bit of skill and hangs a leg out, but it is not a yellow card as there are two other Newcastle players behind him and then you have the back four as well – I can’t give yellow cards for things like that.”

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice