Dermot Gallagher analyses Jaidon Anthony handball vs Everton - 'He turns away'
Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher has analysed Everton's unsuccessful penalty shout for a handball by Jaidon Anthony vs Burnley.
Craig Pawson was right not to award Everton a penalty for a handball against Jaidon Anthony in Burnley’s 0-0 draw against the Toffees on Saturday.
That’s according to former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher, who has analysed the incident alongside Jay Bothroyd for Sky Sports’ Ref Watch show. Both sides had chances to win at Turf Moor, but ultimately, neither did enough to truly earn the three points. However, Evertonians were left fuming late on when Tyler Dibling’s powerful shot was blocked by the arm of Anthony, but no penalty was given by Pawson, even after a VAR review.
Dermot Gallagher assesses Jaidon Anthony handball incident
Former referee Gallagher has backed Pawson and the VAR for their decision-making at Turf Moor, highlighting the natural position of Anthony’s arms and also pointing to the fact that Dibling himself cracked on with the game rather than over-appealing for a penalty.
“I think in the last season, the handball has been interpreted so much better,” said Gallagher. “His arms are tucked in by his side and he turns away, he tries to block it with his body. Even Dibling thinks, let's get on with it.”
Former Cardiff, Wolves and England striker Bothroyd agreed with Gallagher that a penalty would have been harsh. However, he also pointed to a similar incident involving Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall against Brighton earlier this season in which Everton were punished, sympathising with how the Toffees must be feeling.
The Burnley Express has launched a new WhatsApp channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our Burnley Express WhatsApp channel.
“A few weeks ago, the same thing happened to Dewsbury-Hall and a penalty was given. The consistency?” said Bothroyd. “Because Everton's involved in it, they've been punished and then punished again. To be honest, neither are a penalty. But when you give it against Dewsbury-Hall and then not with Anthony?”
What next for Burnley?
Back-to-back draws against Bournemouth and Everton have injected fresh confidence into Burnley following a seven-game losing streak, but there’s still a lot of work to do if the Clarets are going to climb to safety.
Scott Parker’s men are six points adrift of Nottingham Forest in 17th and without a win in nine, with just three victories and 12 points on the board from 18 games. Up next is another home tie against Newcastle United, with Parker facing his former club for the second time in a month. Burnley then face a tough start to 2026, which sees them face Brighton and Liverpool away, and Manchester United and Tottenham Hotspur at home.